Skip to content

Action Priority vs RPN: why the AIAG-VDA FMEA stopped multiplying S, O and D

The 2019 AIAG-VDA FMEA Handbook replaced the Risk Priority Number with Action Priority (High / Medium / Low). What is wrong with S×O×D, what AP does instead, what the 2020 errata changed, and failure modes with the same RPN of 72 and different priorities.

On this page

For decades an FMEA ranked its risks by the Risk Priority Number — severity × occurrence × detection, each rated 1 to 10. The harmonized AIAG-VDA FMEA Handbook (first edition, June 2019, published jointly by AIAG and VDA QMC) replaced it. In the handbook's risk analysis step, the team assigns an Action Priority (AP) of High, Medium or Low instead; AIAG described the change as "the Action Priority (AP) methodology and Tables to replace RPN".

What is wrong with S × O × D

The ratings are ordinal: they put failure modes in order, but the distance between a 3 and a 4 is not the distance between a 7 and an 8, and nothing makes a severity point worth an occurrence point. Multiplying them treats them as quantities anyway. Bowles (2003), a widely cited assessment of RPN prioritization, lists the consequences — among them the gaps in the scale and the duplicate values below, both of which can be checked with nothing more than arithmetic.

  • Most of the scale does not exist. The 1,000 combinations of three 1–10 ratings produce only 120 different RPN values. 880 of the integers from 1 to 1,000 can never occur, and the ones that can are bunched at the low end: 46 of the 100 values up to 100, but only 17 of the 500 above 500.
  • One number, very different risks. RPN 60, 72 and 120 each arise from 24 different combinations. RPN 60 is S 10 · O 2 · D 3, a safety-related effect that is unlikely and fairly well detected. It is also S 2 · O 5 · D 6, a minor annoyance that happens often and is hard to catch. A ranking by RPN, or a fixed RPN threshold, cannot tell them apart.
  • Severity has no special standing. Arithmetic alone also shows this one: a point of detection buys exactly as much RPN as a point of severity, so a better detection control lowers the number of a severity-10 failure mode exactly as much as a one-point drop in its severity would.

What Action Priority does instead

AP is not a product of the ratings. AIAG describes the method as assigning priority to actions "while considering severity, occurrence, and detection individually and in combination with risk-reducing factors"; the priority is read from tables. Each combination of S, O and D maps to H, M or L, and the handbook attaches an expectation for action to each level, strongest for H. The tables themselves, and the handbook's wording for each level, are in the handbook; we do not reproduce them here.

Two details from the handbook's errata (version 2, June 2020) matter in practice:

  • The AP field takes H, M or L only — "N/A" was removed for DFMEA, PFMEA and FMEA-MSR alike.
  • If no action is taken, the AP is not reduced: the risk of failure is unchanged, and so is its priority.

The supplemental FMEA for Monitoring and System Response (FMEA-MSR) has AP tables of its own, rated on monitoring rather than detection — the errata correct those tables separately (§4.6.3).

The same RPN, different priorities

Four failure modes from an injection-molding PFMEA, rated in one worksheet:

Failure modeSODRPNAP
Short shot — structural rib missing83372L
Sink mark — visible surface defect46372M
Warpage — panel deforms on cooling754140M
Weld line — visible knit line655150L

By RPN the short shot and the sink mark are equal, and both rank below warpage and the weld line. AP reads the ratings band by band instead of multiplying them, and changes that order twice:

  • The sink mark is Medium and the short shot Low. At severity 7–8 and occurrence 2–3, the table gives Medium only when detection is weak (5 or worse) and Low otherwise; the short shot's prevention controls keep its occurrence at 3, and its detection is 3. The sink mark happens at occurrence 6, where a severity 4–6 effect is Medium unless detection is rated 1.
  • The weld line, the highest RPN on the sheet, is Low; warpage, below it, is Medium. RPN ranks them the other way round.

Corrected 2026-10-25: an earlier version of this example showed Action Priorities taken from a screenshot made before a correction to the app's AP table (High for the short shot, Low for the sink mark, Medium for the weld line). The ratings above are the app's, by the AIAG-VDA 2019 table.

When a customer still asks for RPN

If a customer's requirements still ask for an RPN, report it — but decide what to work on next by AP, and do not let an RPN threshold overrule it.

Try it in Forge FMEA

Forge FMEA follows the AIAG-VDA seven steps. In the risk analysis step every failure mode gets an AP from the AIAG-VDA 2019 tables as you rate it, using the highest severity among its effects (effects on the end user first), and the worksheet can be filtered to the High items. The RPN is shown beside it for reference, labelled as the legacy metric. The rows above are from the AIAG-VDA PFMEA — Automotive Door Trim Injection Molding sample project that ships with the app.

Forge FMEA runs on your own PC, offline; the data never leaves it.

References

  • AIAG & VDA QMC, FMEA Handbook, 1st ed., June 2019 — Action Priority in the risk analysis step.
  • AIAG, AIAG & VDA FMEA Handbook Errata, version 2, June 2020.
  • VDA QMC, White Paper FMEA — "Die Aufgabenpriorität (AP) ersetzt die Risikoprioritätszahl (RPZ)".
  • J. B. Bowles, "An assessment of RPN prioritization in a failure modes effects and criticality analysis", Annual Reliability and Maintainability Symposium, 2003, pp. 380–386, doi:10.1109/RAMS.2003.1182019.